Here's the study the impact map is based on:

https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2016.046...

The results are from "a new set of climate simulations."

A simulation can easily be wrong. These results say Ireland's GDP growth per capita will be unaffected by climate change and Britain's GDP growth per capita will increase if temperatures rise 2C, but I find it hard to believe these islands wouldn't be hurt.

Why should we trust these maps?

This map seems to be more than lacking. For one it doesn’t seem to take into consideration wet bulb temperatures on the rise, as we have seen now in central and western Europe. It also doesn’t seem to take into account that what really creates issues for economies is high variability, rather than absolute average changes.

We all lose if global temperatures rise, but it's true that those of us living in prosperous industrialised nations (North America, Europe, Australia & NZ, Japan) will be able to cope better with climate change than other countries.

We're simply too comfortable in our current lifestyles to make any changes that might challenge that comfort. Would you fly less? No, didn't so. Eat less meat? Nope. How about unplugging your smartphone from its charger when not in use? Yes! We'll happily do that, despite being utterly inconsequential. (Like bailing the titanic with a teaspoon, to use a description from the book Sustainable Energy - without the hot air.)

We look to governments for action, but if governments took measures to encourage less flying or reducing the farming of meat, we'd never accept it. Most of our politicians are too weak-willed to enact bold legislation and it's mostly because they know we the electorate won't stomach it.

The truth is we love to point accusatory fingers at others but never lift a finger ourselves. Are we all a bunch of hypocrites and simply not willing to admit it?

I wonder whether those numbers take into account the massive refugee crisis that is looming on the horizon. Or wars for arable land and water.

undefined

What's the best (cheapest) investor visa one can get to the post-warming winning countries?

I'm probably going to see people die from heat exhaustion in front of my eyes if I stay here ~50 years.

I'm British. Thanks to my passport and digital nomading I have spent the last 4 years travelling the world. In that time I have gone from thinking of Britain being a relatively normal country (did some bad things in history, but made significant contributions too), to seeing it in the same league as the countries we were taught to despise in school.

I am perhaps a good case study of the shift in thinking that so-called "Winners" need to take. The facts of Britain's (and the rest of the Western World's) history are plain to see. Say in Wikipedia for example, for sure there's bias, but African slavery, Native American decimation, the Opium Wars, the Bengali Famine, the theft of "Commonwealth", to name but a few, are all there. It's that there's simply no impetus to feel any of this, nobody has the power to force us to truly contemplate what we've done, because Britain and its ilk are at the top of the power pyramid.

But travelling suddenly makes all of this personal. "Made in China" takes such a more deeper meaning when you literally made friends with them in their own land. I just can't get so angry about Indian email scammers when I've probably met them or their family and learnt that our Queen wears their precious jewels in her crown like an evil, unfeeling, global bully.

I made these shifts relatively easily, because like most Western people, I have a heart and perhaps ironically I was taught in school to make judgements based on facts. But I needed to be unrooted from my native context, that is just not going to happen on a large enough scale. What if the actual more fundamental problem raised by the Climate Emergency is this large-scale switch in context? What if we put our energy into that instead of reducing C02? Of course that'll never happen, it's chicken and egg, the motivation doesn't come until you understand the bigger picture. What's more the climate serves as a convenient foil for avoiding the existential sea-change by giving us an all too logistical problem to face instead.

I'm glad to see this article on the front page. There is some progress. There are indeed significant seams of Western society which accept such self criticism. Even though most of us did not knowingly cause the damage, we are the only people that can meaningfully take responsibility. It's not fair, but that's the path ahead.

Careful it's a trap, it's the victim mentality trap.

When everything is the fault of others, for sure you cannot do anything about it. There is even a sentence about old white men !

He seem to forget about all the good that came of western society. Electricity, cars, Internet, vaccine, solar cells, wind turbine, the list go on, even the computer he use to type that article.

From wikipedia: "Corruption remains a problem in Sri Lanka, and there is currently very little protection for those who stand up against corruption."

"over 12,000 named individuals who have undergone disappearance after detention by security forces in Sri Lanka, the second highest figure in the world"

"26-year civil war, which ended in 2009"

Look, you have much biggers problem in your own country, that are not the responsibility of others, that your people could do something about.

Maybe some of the flood would have been averted if the government had build damn instead of fighting a civil war for 26 years.

The problem is that victim mentality make you feel good. It's not your fault, it's not in your hand, you don't have to do anything, just blame other people.

I am not saying climate change isn't real, but it's a too much convenient scapegoat because it's out of your control.

There are no winners here. There are losers and bigger losers. Any destabilization will be felt worldwide.

For anyone who is looking for further reading, the term often used with reference to this phenomenon is "Climate Justice".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_justice

(Obviously Climate Justice would be if there WERE just distribution of the effects of climate change - the situation now is probably best termed Climate Injustice).